Thursday, July 24 2014

Dutch burqa ban and French street-prayer ban shows Islamophobia rife in European politics



 The Daily Telegraph has today reported on two developments in Europe which demonstrate how anti-Muslim discourse has found its way into national legislation in European countries.

 The first is the Dutch burqa ban which has been introduced today, making Holland the third country in Europe to implement such a ban after France and Belgium. Only 100 women are thought to wear the burqa in the whole of Holland, though this doesn’t seem to have deterred politicians from passing the law.

From the Daily Telegraph:

“Women caught wearing a burka in public, on the streets, public transport and in schools or hospitals will be fined £330.

“There will be exemptions for mosques, or other religious buildings and for foreign women travelling through the transit lounges of international Dutch airports.

“Cabinet ministers will justify the ban with the argument that the burka does “not fit into our open society and women must participate fully.”


Following elections last year, in which Geert Wilders’ Freedom Party became the third largest political party, Wilders made support for the minority coalition government conditional on the introduction of legislation banning the burqa.

The second story in the DT relates to the prohibition in France of praying on the streets of Paris, legislation which could later be extended to cover the whole of France.

French Interior Minister, Claude Guéant stated that, "My vigilance will be unflinching for the law to be applied. Praying in the street is not dignified for religious practice and violates the principles of secularism”

The legislation relates to the issue of Muslims gathering to pray outside mosques because of a lack of capacity, particularly on a Friday. Under an agreement signed this week, Muslims will be able to use the premises of a vast nearby fire station while awaiting the construction of a bigger mosque.

In December 2010, Marine Le Pen of the far-right National Front party described the practice as the "political act of fundamentalists", and likened the practice to the Nazi occupation of Paris in World War Two, "without the tanks or soldiers".

President Sarkozy’s party denounced her comments but called for a debate specifically on Islam and Secularism. Interior Minister Guéant later “promised a countrywide ban "within months", saying the "street is for driving in, not praying".”

Sheikh Mohamed Salah Hamza, leader of a Parisian mosque which regularly overflows, stated that the mosque would abide by the new law but complained that, "We are not cattle” adding that he was "not entirely satisfied with the new location”.

Both of these examples - the burqa ban and the street prayer ban, illustrate how rife Islamophobia is at a mainstream level in European politics, and how this is being illustrated again and again by legislation which is specifically targeted at Europe’s Muslim communities. The threat of closure of France’s oldest Muslim school, and one of only two state-aided Muslim schools amongst 8000 state-aided faith schools is another case in point. The cases are exemplary of the struggle for equal treatment under the law faced by many European Muslims.

In July of this year, the Commissioner for Human Rights at the Council of Europe, Thomas Hammarberg criticised burqa bans saying they risked alienating, rather than liberating women. He said that debates on the burqa and niqab were an unnecessary distraction from much more important issues and epitomised xenophobic prejudices.

 









Comments

 
0 #2 Morgan 2011-12-12 00:28
A phobia is an irrational fear. Having people block your streets, threaten you for what you eat or drink and firebomb newspaper offices is something to be rationally afraid of.
Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
0 #1 Strange, isn\'t it!LibertyPhile 2011-09-17 13:38
Does it ever occur to you (ENGAGE) that many Europeans, probably the great majority, find hiding the face rude and/or offensive. You only do it if you are ill, very cold, or in mourning, otherwise you are trying to hide something, concealing your true feelings or intentions?

In your world it’s these Europeans who have to change or have to put up with it, not the minority of Muslim women who do it. Why is that?
Quote | Report to administrator
 

This content has been locked. You can no longer post any comment.
If you are experiencing problems please contact info@iengage.org.uk

Engage Publications



Books of Interest