| AYES | NOES | | Afriyie, Adam | Ainger, Nick | | Ainsworth, Mr. Peter | Ainsworth, rh Mr. Bob | | Alexander, Danny | Alexander, rh Mr. Douglas | | Amess, Mr. David | Allen, Mr. Graham | | Ancram, rh Mr. Michael | Anderson, Mr. David | | Arbuthnot, rh Mr. James | Anderson, Janet | | Atkinson, Mr. Peter | Armstrong, rh Hilary | | Bacon, Mr. Richard | Atkins, Charlotte | | Baker, Norman | Austin, Mr. Ian | | Baldry, Tony | Austin, John | | Barker, Gregory | Bailey, Mr. Adrian | | Baron, Mr. John | Baird, Vera | | Barrett, John | Banks, Gordon | | Beith, rh Mr. Alan | Barlow, Ms Celia | | Bellingham, Mr. Henry | Barron, rh Mr. Kevin | | Benyon, Mr. Richard | Battle, rh John | | Beresford, Sir Paul | Beckett, rh Margaret | | Binley, Mr. Brian | Begg, Miss Anne | | Blunt, Mr. Crispin | Bell, Sir Stuart | | Bone, Mr. Peter | Benn, rh Hilary | | Boswell, Mr. Tim | Benton, Mr. Joe | | Bottomley, Peter | Berry, Roger | | Brady, Mr. Graham | Betts, Mr. Clive | | Brake, Tom | Blackman, Liz | | Brazier, Mr. Julian | Blackman-Woods, Dr. Roberta | | Breed, Mr. Colin | Blears, rh Hazel | | Brokenshire, James | Blizzard, Mr. Bob | | Brooke, Annette | Blunkett, rh Mr. David | | Browne, Mr. Jeremy | Borrow, Mr. David S. | | Browning, Angela | Bradshaw, Mr. Ben | | Burns, Mr. Simon | Brennan, Kevin | | Burrowes, Mr. David | Brown, rh Mr. Nicholas | | Burstow, Mr. Paul | Brown, Mr. Russell | | Burt, Alistair | Browne, rh Des | | Burt, Lorely | Bryant, Chris | | Butterfill, Sir John | Buck, Ms Karen | | Cable, Dr. Vincent | Burden, Richard | | Cameron, rh Mr. David | Burgon, Colin | | Campbell, Mr. Gregory | Burnham, rh Andy | | Campbell, rh Sir Menzies | Byers, rh Mr. Stephen | | Carmichael, Mr. Alistair | Byrne, Mr. Liam | | Carswell, Mr. Douglas | Caborn, rh Mr. Richard | | Cash, Mr. William | Cairns, David | | Chope, Mr. Christopher | Campbell, Mr. Alan | | Clappison, Mr. James | Campbell, Mr. Ronnie | | Clark, Greg | Caton, Mr. Martin | | Clarke, rh Mr. Kenneth | Cawsey, Mr. Ian | | Clegg, rh Mr. Nick | Challen, Colin | | Clifton-Brown, Mr. Geoffrey | Chapman, Ben | | Cohen, Harry | Chaytor, Mr. David | | Corbyn, Jeremy | Clapham, Mr. Michael | | Cox, Mr. Geoffrey | Clark, Paul | | Davey, Mr. Edward | Clarke, rh Mr. Charles | | Davies, Mr. Dai | Clarke, rh Mr. Tom | | Davies, David T.C. (Monmouth) | Clelland, Mr. David | | Davies, Philip | Clwyd, rh Ann | | Davis, rh David (Haltemprice and Howden) | Coaker, Mr. Vernon | | Djanogly, Mr. Jonathan | Coffey, Ann | | Dodds, Mr. Nigel | Connarty, Michael | | Donaldson, rh Mr. Jeffrey M. | Cook, Frank | | Dorrell, rh Mr. Stephen | Cooper, Rosie | | Dorries, Mrs. Nadine | Cooper, rh Yvette | | Duncan, Alan | Cousins, Jim | | Duncan Smith, rh Mr. Iain | Crausby, Mr. David | | Dunne, Mr. Philip | Cummings, John | | Durkan, Mark | Cunningham, Mr. Jim | | Ellwood, Mr. Tobias | Cunningham, Tony | | Evans, Mr. Nigel | Curtis-Thomas, Mrs. Claire | | Evennett, Mr. David | David, Mr. Wayne | | Fabricant, Michael | Davidson, Mr. Ian | | Farron, Tim | Davies, Mr. Quentin | | Featherstone, Lynne | Dean, Mrs. Janet | | Field, Mr. Mark | Denham, rh Mr. John | | Fisher, Mark | Devine, Mr. Jim | | Flynn, Paul | Dhanda, Mr. Parmjit | | Foster, Mr. Don | Dismore, Mr. Andrew | | Francois, Mr. Mark | Dobbin, Jim | | Fraser, Christopher | Dobson, rh Frank | | Gale, Mr. Roger | Donohoe, Mr. Brian H. | | Garnier, Mr. Edward | Doran, Mr. Frank | | Gauke, Mr. David | Dowd, Jim | | George, Andrew | Drew, Mr. David | | Gibb, Mr. Nick | Eagle, Angela | | Gidley, Sandra | Eagle, Maria | | Gillan, Mrs. Cheryl | Efford, Clive | | Goldsworthy, Julia | Ellman, Mrs. Louise | | Goodman, Mr. Paul | Engel, Natascha | | Goodwill, Mr. Robert | Ennis, Jeff | | Gove, Michael | Etherington, Bill | | Gray, Mr. James | Farrelly, Paul | | Grayling, Chris | Field, rh Mr. Frank | | Green, Damian | Fitzpatrick, Jim | | Greening, Justine | Flello, Mr. Robert | | Greenway, Mr. John | Flint, rh Caroline | | Grieve, Mr. Dominic | Follett, Barbara | | Gummer, rh Mr. John | Foster, Mr. Michael (Worcester) | | Hague, rh Mr. William | Foster, Michael Jabez (Hastings and Rye) | | Hammond, Mr. Philip | Francis, Dr. Hywel | | Hammond, Stephen | Gapes, Mike | | Hands, Mr. Greg | Gardiner, Barry | | Harper, Mr. Mark | George, rh Mr. Bruce | | Harris, Dr. Evan | Gibson, Dr. Ian | | Harvey, Nick | Gilroy, Linda | | Hayes, Mr. John | Goggins, Paul | | Heald, Mr. Oliver | Goodman, Helen | | Heath, Mr. David | Griffith, Nia | | Heathcoat-Amory, rh Mr. David | Griffiths, Nigel | | Hemming, John | Gwynne, Andrew | | Hendry, Charles | Hain, rh Mr. Peter | | Herbert, Nick | Hall, Mr. Mike | | Hoban, Mr. Mark | Hall, Patrick | | Hogg, rh Mr. Douglas | Hamilton, Mr. David | | Hollobone, Mr. Philip | Hamilton, Mr. Fabian | | Holloway, Mr. Adam | Hanson, rh Mr. David | | Holmes, Paul | Harman, rh Ms Harriet | | Hopkins, Kelvin | Harris, Mr. Tom | | Horwood, Martin | Havard, Mr. Dai | | Hosie, Stewart | Healey, John | | Howard, rh Mr. Michael | Henderson, Mr. Doug | | Howarth, David | Hendrick, Mr. Mark | | Howarth, Mr. Gerald | Hepburn, Mr. Stephen | | Hughes, Simon | Heppell, Mr. John | | Huhne, Chris | Hesford, Stephen | | Hunt, Mr. Jeremy | Heyes, David | | Hunter, Mark | Hill, rh Keith | | Hurd, Mr. Nick | Hodge, rh Margaret | | Jack, rh Mr. Michael | Hodgson, Mrs. Sharon | | Jackson, Mr. Stewart | Hood, Mr. Jim | | Jenkin, Mr. Bernard | Hoon, rh Mr. Geoffrey | | Johnson, Mr. Boris | Hope, Phil | | Jones, Mr. David | Howarth, rh Mr. George | | Jones, Lynne | Howells, Dr. Kim | | Kawczynski, Daniel | Hoyle, Mr. Lindsay | | Keetch, Mr. Paul | Hughes, rh Beverley | | Kennedy, rh Mr. Charles | Humble, Mrs. Joan | | Key, Robert | Hutton, rh Mr. John | | Kirkbride, Miss Julie | Iddon, Dr. Brian | | Knight, rh Mr. Greg | Illsley, Mr. Eric | | Kramer, Susan | Ingram, rh Mr. Adam | | Laing, Mrs. Eleanor | Irranca-Davies, Huw | | Lait, Mrs. Jacqui | James, Mrs. Siân C. | | Lamb, Norman | Jenkins, Mr. Brian | | Lancaster, Mr. Mark | Johnson, rh Alan | | Lansley, Mr. Andrew | Johnson, Ms Diana R. | | Laws, Mr. David | Jones, Helen | | Leech, Mr. John | Jones, Mr. Kevan | | Leigh, Mr. Edward | Jones, Mr. Martyn | | Letwin, rh Mr. Oliver | Jowell, rh Tessa | | Liddell-Grainger, Mr. Ian | Joyce, Mr. Eric | | Lidington, Mr. David | Kaufman, rh Sir Gerald | | Lilley, rh Mr. Peter | Keeble, Ms Sally | | Llwyd, Mr. Elfyn | Keeley, Barbara | | Loughton, Tim | Keen, Alan | | Luff, Peter | Kelly, rh Ruth | | Mackay, rh Mr. Andrew | Kennedy, rh Jane | | Maclean, rh David | Khan, Mr. Sadiq | | MacNeil, Mr. Angus | Kidney, Mr. David | | Main, Anne | Knight, Jim | | Malins, Mr. Humfrey | Kumar, Dr. Ashok | | Maples, Mr. John | Ladyman, Dr. Stephen | | Marshall-Andrews, Mr. Robert | Laxton, Mr. Bob | | Mates, rh Mr. Michael | Lazarowicz, Mark | | Maude, rh Mr. Francis | Lepper, David | | May, rh Mrs. Theresa | Levitt, Tom | | McDonnell, Dr. Alasdair | Lewis, Mr. Ivan | | McDonnell, John | Linton, Martin | | McGrady, Mr. Eddie | Lloyd, Tony | | McIntosh, Miss Anne | Love, Mr. Andrew | | McLoughlin, rh Mr. Patrick | Lucas, Ian | | Mercer, Patrick | Mackinlay, Andrew | | Miller, Mrs. Maria | MacShane, rh Mr. Denis | | Milton, Anne | Mactaggart, Fiona | | Moore, Mr. Michael | Mahmood, Mr. Khalid | | Moss, Mr. Malcolm | Malik, Mr. Shahid | | Mulholland, Greg | Mallaber, Judy | | Mundell, David | Mann, John | | Murrison, Dr. Andrew | Marris, Rob | | Neill, Robert | Marsden, Mr. Gordon | | Newmark, Mr. Brooks | Martlew, Mr. Eric | | O'Brien, Mr. Stephen | McAvoy, rh Mr. Thomas | | Oaten, Mr. Mark | McCabe, Steve | | Öpik, Lembit | McCafferty, Chris | | Osborne, Mr. George | McCarthy, Kerry | | Ottaway, Richard | McCarthy-Fry, Sarah | | Paice, Mr. James | McDonagh, Siobhain | | Paterson, Mr. Owen | McFadden, Mr. Pat | | Pelling, Mr. Andrew | McFall, rh John | | Penrose, John | McGovern, Mr. Jim | | Pickles, Mr. Eric | McGuire, Mrs. Anne | | Prentice, Mr. Gordon | McIsaac, Shona | | Price, Adam | McKechin, Ann | | Prisk, Mr. Mark | McKenna, Rosemary | | Pritchard, Mark | McNulty, rh Mr. Tony | | Pugh, Dr. John | Meale, Mr. Alan | | Randall, Mr. John | Merron, Gillian | | Redwood, rh Mr. John | Michael, rh Alun | | Reid, Mr. Alan | Milburn, rh Mr. Alan | | Rennie, Willie | Miliband, rh David | | Rifkind, rh Sir Malcolm | Miliband, rh Edward | | Riordan, Mrs. Linda | Miller, Andrew | | Robathan, Mr. Andrew | Mitchell, Mr. Austin | | Robertson, Angus | Moffat, Anne | | Robertson, Hugh | Moffatt, Laura | | Robertson, Mr. Laurence | Mole, Chris | | Robinson, Mrs. Iris | Moon, Mrs. Madeleine | | Robinson, rh Mr. Peter | Moran, Margaret | | Rogerson, Dan | Morden, Jessica | | Rosindell, Andrew | Morgan, Julie | | Rowen, Paul | Morley, rh Mr. Elliot | | Ruffley, Mr. David | Mountford, Kali | | Russell, Bob | Mudie, Mr. George | | Sanders, Mr. Adrian | Mullin, Mr. Chris | | Scott, Mr. Lee | Munn, Meg | | Selous, Andrew | Murphy, Mr. Denis | | Shapps, Grant | Murphy, Mr. Jim | | Shepherd, Mr. Richard | Murphy, rh Mr. Paul | | Short, rh Clare | Naysmith, Dr. Doug | | Simmonds, Mark | Norris, Dan | | Simpson, Alan | O'Brien, Mr. Mike | | Simpson, David | O'Hara, Mr. Edward | | Simpson, Mr. Keith | Osborne, Sandra | | Soames, Mr. Nicholas | Owen, Albert | | Soulsby, Sir Peter | Palmer, Dr. Nick | | Spelman, Mrs. Caroline | Pearson, Ian | | Spicer, Sir Michael | Plaskitt, Mr. James | | Spring, Mr. Richard | Pope, Mr. Greg | | Stanley, rh Sir John | Pound, Stephen | | Steen, Mr. Anthony | Prentice, Bridget | | Streeter, Mr. Gary | Prescott, rh Mr. John | | Stuart, Mr. Graham | Primarolo, rh Dawn | | Stunell, Andrew | Prosser, Gwyn | | Swayne, Mr. Desmond | Purchase, Mr. Ken | | Swinson, Jo | Purnell, rh James | | Swire, Mr. Hugo | Rammell, Bill | | Syms, Mr. Robert | Raynsford, rh Mr. Nick | | Tapsell, Sir Peter | Reed, Mr. Andy | | Taylor, Mr. Ian | Reed, Mr. Jamie | | Taylor, Matthew | Reid, rh John | | Taylor, Dr. Richard | Robertson, John | | Teather, Sarah | Robinson, Mr. Geoffrey | | Thurso, John | Rooney, Mr. Terry | | Turner, Mr. Andrew | Roy, Mr. Frank | | Tyrie, Mr. Andrew | Ruane, Chris | | Vaizey, Mr. Edward | Ruddock, Joan | | Vara, Mr. Shailesh | Russell, Christine | | Viggers, Peter | Ryan, rh Joan | | Villiers, Mrs. Theresa | Salter, Martin | | Walker, Mr. Charles | Sarwar, Mr. Mohammad | | Wallace, Mr. Ben | Sharma, Mr. Virendra | | Walter, Mr. Robert | Shaw, Jonathan | | Wareing, Mr. Robert N. | Sheerman, Mr. Barry | | Waterson, Mr. Nigel | Sheridan, Jim | | Watkinson, Angela | Simon, Mr. Siôn | | Webb, Steve | Skinner, Mr. Dennis | | Weir, Mr. Mike | Slaughter, Mr. Andy | | Whittingdale, Mr. John | Smith, rh Mr. Andrew | | Widdecombe, rh Miss Ann | Smith, Ms Angela C. (Sheffield, Hillsborough) | | Wiggin, Bill | Smith, Angela E. (Basildon) | | Willetts, Mr. David | Smith, Geraldine | | Williams, Hywel | Snelgrove, Anne | | Williams, Mr. Roger | Southworth, Helen | | Williams, Stephen | Spellar, rh Mr. John | | Willis, Mr. Phil | Spink, Bob | | Willott, Jenny | Starkey, Dr. Phyllis | | Wilshire, Mr. David | Stewart, Ian | | Wilson, Mr. Rob | Stoate, Dr. Howard | | Wilson, Sammy | Strang, rh Dr. Gavin | | Wishart, Pete | Straw, rh Mr. Jack | | Yeo, Mr. Tim | Stuart, Ms Gisela | | Young, rh Sir George | Sutcliffe, Mr. Gerry | | Younger-Ross, Richard | Taylor, Ms Dari | | | Taylor, David | | Tellers for the Ayes: | Thomas, Mr. Gareth | | | Timms, rh Mr. Stephen | | James Duddridge and | Tipping, Paddy | | Jeremy Wright | Todd, Mr. Mark | | | Touhig, rh Mr. Don | | | Trickett, Jon | | | Turner, Dr. Desmond | | | Turner, Mr. Neil | | | Twigg, Derek | | | Vis, Dr. Rudi | | | Walley, Joan | | | Waltho, Lynda | | | Watson, Mr. Tom | | | Whitehead, Dr. Alan | | | Wicks, Malcolm | | | Williams, rh Mr. Alan | | | Williams, Mrs. Betty | | | Wills, Mr. Michael | | | Wilson, Phil | | | Winnick, Mr. David | | | Winterton, rh Ms Rosie | | | Woodward, rh Mr. Shaun | | | Woolas, Mr. Phil | | | Wright, Mr. Anthony | | | Wright, David | | | Wright, Mr. Iain | | | Wyatt, Derek | | | | | | Tellers for the Noes: | | | | | | Alison Seabeck and | | | Mr. Dave Watts | | |